Now that the Democrats have won the midterms, we see that some are interested in ending things like the filibuster and making radical changes. Is that a path to actual future Democratic victories?
I understand the seduction. You’ve just won some major elections. You have a majority. Why shouldn’t you use it? You’ve just been seemingly vindicated by the voters, whereas the current president hasn’t. So now the idea is to change the system: let’s end the filibuster, the rule that in the Senate you need more than just a simple majority to pass anything.
That rule has been an annoyance to a lot of people. Even Donald Trump suggested that the Republicans get rid of it, and they didn’t. It used to be that you literally had to filibuster by holding a long speech. We’ve probably all seen past records of that, or you can look them up. Now it’s only the threat of a filibuster that remains.
Why should ending it be a good idea? The excuse given right now is that getting rid of the filibuster makes everything more democratic, and that a simple majority can then make the changes needed. But anything can be excused by claiming it makes things more democratic.
Part of a democracy, however, is not just simple majority rule. It is also the protection of the structure itself that allows the democratic republic to exist. The idea that simple majority rule is the core of democracy is not quite correct. Some things have to be protected from being changed too easily. That’s why some parliaments have two-thirds requirements for anything that changes the constitutional order, and the filibuster is one of the tools that protects that.
The other protection for the political minority is the Electoral College. A lot of people agitate against the Electoral College because it seems so quaint, and it’s not really practiced the way it used to be. But the main principle behind it has always been to prevent large, populous states from outcrowding the less populated states.
We are not simply one country in the United States. We are a collection of different states that agreed to be with each other. These fifty states and a handful of territories have struck a very delicate balance. That balance exists, and continues to exist, because of different federalist institutions. Mainly that’s the Senate, where every state, no matter its size, has two senators. It’s the filibuster, which protects against some of these larger changes. And it’s the Electoral College, which makes sure that having a majority in the populous states doesn’t mean everybody else has to follow.
Why is that important? Because different states have different interests, and even the big, populous states rely on the other states. If the interests of largely rural, less populated states were continuously violated, and that would happen, we would damage the relationship with the states where a lot of our food, our energy, and many other resources come from.
A population majority alone is not enough to create a stable democracy. We’ve seen this already in history: ancient Athens was the prime example of where that doesn’t work. There can be a tyranny of the majority. If you go only by simple majorities, you create a scorched-earth policy where you win an election and destroy everything that came before.
Now, you could say: shouldn’t the Democrats do it, because the Republicans might? Sure, but we’ve seen that the Republicans didn’t do it. For decades now, smart Senate leaders and smart senators have prevented this change from being made. Because there’s one insight that many people who win elections don’t want to hear: it’s always about the next election.
There are two important things to learn from the midterms. First, it seems that gerrymandering didn’t work the way some Republican states had hoped it would. Voters aren’t that stupid. Second, many of the candidates who won were a little more moderate. That should tell the Democrats something, and it should tell the Republicans something, too. Going all in with an agenda that clearly pleases only parts of your political party, not even everybody in it, is a dangerous game to play.
The Democratic Socialists are not Democrats. If you demand that the structures of this republic be demolished (look at the DSA program), then that is not what the Democratic Party has stood for. If you normalize terms like socialism, then through its own inner logic you are eventually calling for the return of a system I grew up with and that I don’t wish on anybody. It always starts with saying, “Well, we just want to do this. We just want to do this. We just want to do this.” The socialist logic leads to real existing socialism, which some in the US call communism.
The Democratic Party has always stood for a more moderate, pragmatic approach, which is best called social democracy. At least that’s been true in recent decades; before that, the Democratic Party stood for other things.
If you remove barriers to decisions, if you make compromise less necessary by removing something like the filibuster, what happens when you lose next time? The only thing that protects the achievements of previous administrations and previous decisions is something like the filibuster. If you undo it, just wait and see what happens the next time the other side is in power.
That should be the thought. The thought should not be, “How can we now quickly do everything we always wanted?” The question should be, “How do we protect, in the long term, a structure that has now clearly vindicated those who said that whatever is going on right now is a little too extreme?”
The people don’t want extremes. If you play to the center and to the moderates, you lose the loud extremist wing of your party. But you’ll keep winning over people on the other side who say, “Yeah, we don’t quite like the extremists on our side either.”
In the end, it shouldn’t matter which party you support. You should support the continued existence of a system that has survived, and improved itself significantly, since its founding.
So I would consider a more humble approach to election wins. Humility may not look sexy right now, but it increases your chances for the next round.
[This was originally posted to YouTube as a video. This post is a slightly abbreviated transcript, preserving the oral style of the video.]
